Vital Football

Latest Nottingham Forest News

Calderwood v The Critics. Who Was Right?

Calderwood v The Critics. Who Was Right?

First things first, I have to put my hand up and say that by the time January '08 came round I was a fully paid up member of the 'Calderwood Out' brigade and had just about had enough of his tactics, substitutions and ever changing squad formations. But now that the dust has settled on what was a fantastic last day smash and grab on the second automatic promotion place, I have to ask. Have I done CC a massive disservice?

Following the 'Yeovil debacle,' Calderwood was charged with one thing and that was to get Forest promoted and out of League 1. Failure to do that would cost him his job and he knew it. Although that can't make the job at hand any easier, he does get paid handsomely for doing it. So fair play to him for getting us up and all without the need for the dreaded Play Offs.

I will also admit to not being too enthralled by his initial appointment, but he won me over pretty quickly and I soon put to the back of my mind the warnings and taunts of Cobblers fans, who I thought were bitter and twisted at his move to the City Ground. I never blamed him for the failings in last season's Play Offs, because it wasn't entirely his team. It was mainly one he'd inherrited.

I thought this season started with some promise, despite the first win proving hard to come by. I was very impressed with his summer signings and could see the reasoning behind them and backed him and the team all the way. Throughout the season though, we stuttered and never really got going, taking until the end of it to construct a decent run of games unbeaten. Talk about timing, eh. Many fans were calling for his head from an early stage in the season, but I thought he should be given until Christmas to prove himself. By that time, it was looking as so the wheels were coming off and the season was threatening to fall away from us.

It was the 3-0 away defeat to Gillingham at the end of December that finally made me turn against CC and all that he stood for. It was one of many abject displays we'd been put through and it wouldn't be the last. I thought he should have gone then in all honestly and like many, I made my feelings known on the message boards.

Even worse defeats and performances than Gillingham and Luton before it were to follow. Swindon and Bournemouth would make those look like world beating displays by the lads. By the end of January and another disappointing showing in the transfer market, many fans, myself included were resigned to another year in League 1. I've supported this club for my entire adult life and don't consider myself fickle. I try and justify criticism and I have to say, CC was deserving of the criticism he got.

This division has been weaker than any of the three previous years we've been in it and we got out because of the failings of Donny and Carlisle. Not because of some masterful leadership from CC and dynamic performances on the pitch. Take a look at the last day promotion winning performance over Yeovil and put the emotion to one side and you will see yet another woeful display, But hey. It's the winning that counts and not one of us will complain about the result at the end of the day.

Criticism aside, I think that Colin Calderwood has earned himself a clean slate next season. I have 100% absolute faith in his ability to make good signings. McLeary, Ormerod, Hoskins, Agogo, Smith, Cohen, Davies, and even Lennon are testament to that. We can forgive him the signing of Lockwood.

He has to learn from his mistakes though and there have been many. He has to find a formation and stick to it. Play the players in their strongest and best positions and above all else, be more attack minded and positive in his outlook and approach to games.

If he can get us playing football again and playing it on the deck, he may find the fans a little more forgiving. We're a harsh bunch, of that there's no doubt and he has been criticised, but fairly in my opinion. I hope he has a successful season in the Championship and that he can build a future for himself at this club. We need stability to achieve success and move forward. I hope it's with CC, but for me the jury is out until he proves himself next season. Good luck to him and well done to him for getting us out of the hell hole that was League 1.

Writer:guinless
Date:Tuesday May 20 2008
Time: 7:21PM

Best of Vital Network

Comments

0
Calderwood got you promoted, I can't see anything wrong with that. The league season is a marathon not a sprint. What you should be asking is can he keep you up next season, does he inspire confidence?
Dean1
20/05/2008 21:08:00
0
Agree with some parts, disagree with others - arguably, I would say that this has been one of the tougher years in L1 - minus the so called superstars that took us down! He got us up with his team, that gelled at the right time (the others failing - fair enough, but our momentum created the pressure & self doubt which led to their demise) - the last game a 3-2 win over Yeovil - we had the game in the bag & could have scored more at any time - the players were clearly as nervous as us fans. I have always advocated consistency & maintained support where possible for a fledgling manager - next season will determine - whether he continues to learn & perhaps matures into a true great! I hope that he'll become a Forest Legend!!!
Our Kids Dad
21/05/2008 09:51:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Nottingham Forest Articles

Forest Confirm Derby Kick-Off Changes

The league matches against Derby, scheduled for December and March, have had changes to the kick-off times. Kick-offs have been brought forward a couple of hours to 1pm.

Squad Assessment Then Montainer Enters The Market

Montainer will now start assessing his options before he starts looking to recruit 'several players' to help Nottingham Forest have a successful Championship season.

Vellios Seals Forest Switch

Montanier has made his first signing since being confirmed at Nottingham Forest's new Head Coach. He's snapped up former Everton striker Vellios from Iraklis Thessaloniki.

Montanier Relishing Forest Challenge

New head coach Philippe Montanier has now been presented to the media for his first press conference, and he's obviously excited about the challenge Nottingham Forest...

Archived Vital Forest Articles

Vital Forest articles from

Site Journalists

Kev Finnegan
no email
Profile
Our Kids Dad
Editor email
Profile
Those Feet
no email
Profile
WillT
no email
Profile
Galaxy42
no email
Profile
Mark2310
no email
Profile
bazforest
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

MK Dons MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
de Vries14%
Lichaj0%
Mills1%
Fox1%
Jokic10%
Tesche0%
Gardner1%
Cohen35%
O Burke1%
O'Grady1%
Osborn3%
Sub - Mancienne1%
Sub - Assombalonga30%
Sub - Mendes da Graca2%

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
C Burnley 46 26 15 5 93 37
P Middlesbrough 46 26 11 9 89 32
3 Brighton 46 24 17 5 89 30
4 Hull City 46 24 11 11 83 34
5 Derby County 46 21 15 10 78 23
6 Sheff Wed 46 19 17 10 74 21
7 Ipswich 46 18 15 13 69 2
8 Cardiff 46 17 17 12 68 5
9 Brentford 46 19 8 19 65 5
10 Birmingham 46 16 15 15 63 4
11 Preston 46 15 17 14 62 0
12 Q.P.R. 46 14 18 14 60 0
13 Leeds Utd 46 14 17 15 59 -8
14 Wolves 46 14 16 16 58 -5
15 Blackburn 46 13 16 17 55 0
16 Forest 46 13 16 17 55 -4
17 Reading 46 13 13 20 52 -7
18 Bristol City 46 13 13 20 52 -17
19 Huddersfield 46 13 12 21 51 -11
20 Fulham 46 12 15 19 51 -13
21 Rotherham 46 13 10 23 49 -18
R Charlton 46 9 13 24 40 -40
R MK Dons 46 9 12 25 39 -30
R Bolton 46 5 15 26 30 -40
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News

Recent Nottingham Forest Results (view all)

Nottingham Forest Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.Jimmy Gordon778
2.Apollyon460
3.Pope John XXIII396
4.PVH385
5.radfordinlondon293
6.the jock273
7.Widdow240
8.in_the_top_one229
9.Marco Polo212
10.Ingy199