UK time is: 08:46:47
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

In Support Of Calderwood

There's one thing that I'm unable to find an answer to in the Calderwood in/out debate: would another manager really change anything? As the old cliche goes: 'the more things change, the more they stay the same'. Forest have had a ridiculous rate of turnover in managers in the past decade or so and none of them have been able to turn us back into a club even half as good as we once were. Maybe now it is time for stability?

Usually the reason you get a 'honeymoon' period with a new manager is that the players had lost faith with the old gaffer and suddenly want to impress the new one. The players certainly want to play for Colin Calderwood and I think that is a massive factor in CC not being sacked thus far. I think it's clear for everyone to see that the team spirit is fantastic - much better than has been seen at the City Ground for many years. For whatever reason we're just falling short at the moment but I'm certain that will change and we will stay up. Doughty knows that these players won't play any better under a different man and therefore change would only bring about more instability and ultimate failure.

The performances this season have, excluding Wolves, the second half against Norwich and Sheffield United, been pretty decent - certainly as much as anyone should expect from a newly (not to mention fortunately) promoted side. In quite a few games we've looked a brilliant attacking force but somehow haven't managed to find the back of the net. We could easily have had five both at Coventry and against Blackpool. I heard a stat the other day that said, despite having around half a dozen penalties against us, we haven't been given a single one. Teams like Cardiff, on the other hand, are into double figures. Even if we'd only had three or four, that could quite easily have given us another eight or so points by converting draws into wins.

I know this sounds like I'm clutching at straws but I'm basically trying to highlight the unbelievably bad luck Forest have been dealt throughout the first half of this season.

Another example of this are the injuries we have, once again, suffered with. We've been without our two new strikers, Earnshaw and Garner, for a hefty combined period of time. Even now neither of them can really be counted as fully fit. We lost Moussi early on in the season and, despite a slight dip in form, he'd really looked the part until his injury. McGugan was out for a while with both an injury and a suspension, followed by yet another injury which has kept him out of the last couple of games. Even Bennett who might not be Championship quality has been sorely missed. He's got such amazing determination and always plays like he'd rather be at Nottingham Forest than any other club in the World.

I know I'll get slated for this as most people think he's had more than enough already, but I really think Colin just needs more time. We look like we've become a bit more solid at the back recently and I'm sure it's only a matter of time before the goals start flying in. We've got a very young squad and a very young manager and they're growing together, as a team, with each game that passes. He may not be the most tactically astute manager in the world at the moment but, as I say, he's learning just like the players.

In Joe Garner I think we have a top quality striker. He might not score 30 goals a season but, once he's fully fit and adjusted to this level, he'll easily get 15-20. Couple that with the fact he's playing alongside Robert Earnshaw who, when fit, is one of the most proven goalscorers at this level, and I can't see how we can fail to start hitting the back of the net soon.

Lewis McGugan had started to show, before his injury, that he can really make the step up to Championship level. He's intelligent on the ball and in the pass, he's skillful and can't half hit a ball, too.

Guy Moussi, after playing only a handful of games for us, was already being branded as the new Patrick Viera. Who knows how good he could be for us with a decent amount of Championship games under his belt?

Calderwood has certainly shown that he is shrewd when it comes to transfers. He's got rid of most of our poor players and has replaced them with much better ones. If he's given the money in January, which with Doughty at the helm I'm sure he will, he will surely strengthen the key areas - Camp signed permanently, a solid centre-back, an experienced midfielder and a different type of striker to the three similar ones we already have.

If the worst case scenario come to fruition and we were relegated from this League, which I'm sure we won't be, I think we'd be very strong next season and would bounce straight back. If we go down the best chance we have of keeping our young stars is with Calderwood in charge - he's brought many of them through and they genuinely appear to have massive respect for him.

I know the majority of the people on this forum have already made their mind up and there's nothing I can do to change that, but I hope some of the points I've made have made you think a little harder about whether getting rid would be the best thing to do.

Jack.

Thanks to Jack for taking time out to give us his views. If you would like to have your say on anything Forest related, you can contact forest@vitalfootball.co.uk.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!




Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: guinless Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Wednesday December 17 2008

Time: 7:34AM

Your Comments

Good article Jack. However I disagree on the point that ND knows these players won,t play better under another manager. Well tell that to John Robertson and Tony Woodcock, both of whom were on a one way ticket to oblivion before BC arrived and turned both into World Cup players. A new man xcan change things, the thing is we need the right man to be appointed. I don't trust ND or MA to do that though!!
RedSmedDownUnder
I've looked at so many opinions on here for the last 12 months but this has made me register an account, this is spot on! a bit of stability is exactly what the club needs right now. I think wolves this season are a perfect example of this (yes they have spent a huge amount of money as well) CC has got everyone playing for him and its time to throw all our support behind him and the team
jimpanzee
Welcome Jim. CC has certainly got the fans opinion of him divided, that's for sure.
guinless
Good article Jack - I do share one of your worries, which is - new man comes in, gets exeprienced players, kids get dis-illusioned & are allowed to leave for next to nowt!
Our Kids Dad
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Nottingham Forest Articles

Stats: Nottingham Forest v Fulham (Thursday September 18 2014)

There's Only One Chris Cohen!!! (Thursday September 18 2014)

Bash9's Forest Player Ratings!! (Wednesday September 17 2014)

Forest v Fulham Vital Preview (Wednesday September 17 2014)

Stats: Nottingham Forest v Derby County (Tuesday September 16 2014)

Louis Laing's Lane Loan! (Friday September 12 2014)

Forest v Derby Vital Match Preview! (Friday September 12 2014)

Forest v Derby - It's A Sell Out! (Thursday September 11 2014)

Bash9 - August's Player Of The Month! (Thursday September 11 2014)

Archived Nottingham Forest Articles

List All Vital Forest Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Jimmy Gordon 361
2. PVH 334
3. Calvin Plummer 249
4. da fuq 159
5. LyttleByLyttle 151
6. Mr Angry 122
7. Ingy 120
8. Southern red 114
9. MarvinsPA 109
10. Cornelius_Smiff 103

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Forest 2 - 0 Blackpool
Forest 4 - 0 Reading
Forest 1 - 1 Derby County
Forest 5 - 3 Fulham
Bournemouth 1 - 2 Forest
Sheff Wed 0 - 1 Forest

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Forest 7 5 2 0 +10 17
2. Norwich 7 5 1 1 +10 16
3. Watford 7 5 0 2 +7 15
4. Wolves 7 4 2 1 +4 14
5. Charlton 7 3 4 0 +3 13
6. Reading 7 4 1 2 +1 13
7. Derby County 7 3 3 1 +5 12

Breaking League News

Man of the Match: David Edgar
Birmingham : 19/09/2014 08:26:00
Pannu Out of BCFC
Birmingham : 19/09/2014 08:21:00
Howe: Our principles will remain the same
Bournemouth : 19/09/2014 08:19:00
Elphick: We need to be brave on the ball
Bournemouth : 19/09/2014 08:13:00
Francis: It's become a recurring theme
Bournemouth : 19/09/2014 08:10:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Djamel Abdoun is yet to find a new club - would you keep him to see if he can turn his Forest career
Suggested By:  OKD
Yes - given current injuries 71%
No - get rid asap 29%