Vital Football

Latest Nottingham Forest News

Famous Last Words

Famous Last Words

Formations eh, don`t you just love em? As soon a team has a bad result or there is a poor performance, such as the Orient debacle, the 'F` word rears its ugly head again.

England's horrendous performance in Croatia a couple of months ago highlighted this more than ever with every pundit the length and breadth of the country rubbishing the formation. Surely professional footballers (well that`s apparently what they are) can play pretty much any formation if they are good enough? England, are supposed to have so many great midfielders and yet putting three passes together seemed like asking them to achieve a first class honours degree in astrophysics. To me England`s problems are not so much to do with formation but a number of injuries to key players and a problem with motivation/confidence.

Forest have also been the subject of lots of debate regarding the formation as a result of some insipid performances of late, but the cold hard fact is that a few of the players are not good enough to do the job asked of them, regardless of the formation. Equally, despite the size of the squad, there is a dearth of wide players and left footers resulting in a few square pegs in round holes. For example, Holt cannot pass to save his life and seems to remove a lot of the good from Sammy`s game when he plays alongside him to boot. Grant Holt on the left wing and big Wes playing as a makeshift right back are prime examples of a lack of players who can play in those positions. Therefore, in my humble opinion, the Orient game did not expose our tactics as much as the players or the positions they were occupying

Good players/managers dictate games and good tactics/formations help, but they will not paper over the cracks. We play in a poor league where a little bit of simple, good passing football can make you look like Brazil - just look at the Crewe game for example. No-one mentioned the tactics then did they? The fact is that Crewe allowed us to play but Orient and Bournemouth did not. This exposes the limitations of the players more than the formation

When it comes down to it there are only two standard formations anyway, 4-4-2 and 3-5-2, and although both in come in many guises these days they are still only variations on a theme. Chelsea's oh so effective formation is only that because they have world class players in every position.

It sounds like I am being harsh and a little downcast considering our lofty position but I do still think we will get promotion with this funny 3-4-3 formation we are playing. My only plea is that instead of addressing the formation, we should look at a few of the personnel instead.


Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:
Date:Saturday December 30 2006
Time: 2:19PM

Comments

0
A bit out of date now but the message is still the same. Pity we are no longer in such a 'lofty position' anymore either.
wemaybefamousagain
30/12/2006 18:16:00
0
a good article....most clubs and fans have this debate after every match....
ernshaw
02/01/2007 12:25:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Nottingham Forest Articles

Time to stop talking and start delivering at Forest

Time to stop talking and start delivering at Forest

EFL Clubs Agree Early Transfer Window Closure

Within the last hour the EFL have confirmed that member clubs have agreed to changes to the summer transfer window deadline and from next season...

EFL Summer Transfer Window Vote Imminent

EFL member clubs are set to vote on changes to the summer transfer window today.

Point Made With Second Half Response

Nottingham Forest manager Aitor Karanka has said he feels the players made a point with their second half response in the game against Reading.

Nottingham Forest Archived Articles

Vital Forest articles from

Site Journalists

Kev Finnegan
no email
Profile
Our Kids Dad
Editor email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Has Karanka flattered to deceive at the City Ground?
Suggested By: The Forest
Yes19%
No36%
Unsure45%
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Nottingham Forest Results (view all)

Nottingham Forest Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.Ingy211
2.Apollyon189
3.Pope John XXIII181
4.Strawberry Avenger178
5.orbitalforest173
6.Old Red Fart153
7.Calvin Plummer111
8.mao tse tung111
9.the jock109
10.AdebolaCornflakes109
Vital Football Comment