UK time is: 07:40:05
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Nottingham Forest 0 - Carlisle United 1

City Ground

March 3, 2008

Attendance: 28,487

Forest Let Down Fans Again

An expectant, vocal and supportive crowd turned up at the City Ground to once again get let down and disappointed, by the hapless bottlers that call themselves Nottingham Forest. That statement may be viewed by many to be a little harsh, especially when they are being managed by a man who appears to be short on tactical nous. But the sad fact is, that this team fails on a consistent basis to rise to the challenge of a big game.

Tonight's was indeed a big game and the prize for the victors was second place in the table. Forest had only been beaten once at home prior to this and should have been confident. In fact they started brightly and were unlucky to go in at the break at 0-0. But the second half was where it was lost, or more pertinently thrown away.

To be honest, I can't be arsed to write a detailed match report, as I'm too angry. We had chances for sure. Agogo went close. Bennett forced Westwood to make a brilliant save from a bullet of a header and Holt missed a sitter, when it looked easier to score. Carlisle's best chances came from wayward shots and were at times out played by some enterprising play in the first half from Forest.

At the interval fans could feel justifiably content with the efforts put in by the lads. But the second half performance, defied belief. Once again they bottled it. They failed to stand up and be counted and just threw in the towel. Without wanting to be too unkind to the visitors, they were nothing special. They defended well and tried to hit us on the break, but rarely looked like getting the better of us.

We looked disjointed in the second half. Once again Commons was drifting all over the place and Holt was playing too deep. The ball was bouncing off every one of them and no one could put a foot on it. Passing the ball to a Red shirt was seemingly impossible and we lacked the zest for the game that we had in the first period.

It's hard to single out individuals for blame, except Smith, but more on him in a bit because he deserves his own special paragraph in this one. With the exception of Julian Bennett, who I thought had a good night and was unlucky not to have scored in the first half, it's hard to pick a player out. McG huffed and puffed and Cohen worked hard. Perch didn't really let himself down and I was worried when I saw his name on the team sheet. Wilson had one or two worrying moments, but otherwise did OK. Holt wouldn't have scored in a month of Sunday's and Agogo looked tired, despite having a week off. Clingan and the rest were OK, without being spectacular. So where do our problems lie? Or more to the point, what is the cause of them? I for one, now believe the problem is with the manager.

Calderwood is incapable of sending out an attacking side, especially at home because he fears losing. If he sent the side out in the second half with the same intent as the first, the three points would have been ours for sure. But he didn't. We were a completely different team after the break. We were spineless and passionless. That has to be down to him. Whatever he said to them in the dressing room, it must have been the most demotivational speech ever. *Message to Calderwood. If we're playing well, say nowt.*

And so, onto the goal. Not wanting to be harsh. It was a goalkeeping gaffe. The ball ran across the box and Smith ran after it. He had it in his arms and conspired to drop it. End result, is it lands at the feet of Graham, who said 'Ta very much' and knocked it into an empty net. You could see whatever confidence the hapless number one had drain from his body, because he couldn't get a thing right after it. Morgan was to be seen screaming what I took to be harsh words at him on a number of occasions. He would start to come for balls and then retreat. He couldn't kick and he couldn't throw. The problem for us in all this, is he has no competition. Barry Richardson at 38 years of age and who has something of a calamitous reputation himself isn't the answer. Go and get a keeper Colin. We need one. The guys confidence is shot and he needs a rest. It will do him good. He is young and he has the potential to be a great keeper, but carrying on in this vein will do him and the club no good whatsoever.

So, what now? It's looking increasingly like the playoffs again and that's if we're lucky. To do that we need a striker or even two. But we don't look like getting them. Oh, and a keeper as well. I said weeks ago that it was Deja Vu and sadly that's looking like the truest thing I've said this year.

Finally a special mention to Mr. Martin Atkinson, our Premier League Referee. You were a joke mate. Countless decisions were wrong for both sides and it may sound like sour grapes, but most of them seemed to affect us. I hope we don't see you for a long time and that will probably be too soon.

Star Player

Julian Bennett.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

The Journalist

Writer: guinless Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday March 3 2008

Time: 11:23PM

Your Comments

I had a rare chance to watch the League 1 footie on TV over here in Czechia. I more or less agree with your report bar your go on the ref. He was ok, no major mistakes, it's bitterly sour grapes on your part mate ;) Actually you were lucky not to concede a pen in the 1st half when Holt knocked down Carlisle man in the box with his elbow.
Czech_Jack
Ahh, cheers mate . You just made me feel a whole lot better. The ref was a joke Fact!
guinless
Vocal fans? Only vocal in abusing Smith and Perch - and I'm sure I sit near you! :)
goddammit
Indeed you do Sir and I thought in the 1st half we were vocal and supportive. It all went tits up 2nd half and the support reverted to type. I thought Perch had a decent game and I too heard some barracking of him. Smith was understandably slated by the fans. He's a good keeper, but he needs to learn. He has some obvious flaws to his game that don't seem to be getting better. We need a new keeper, if only to give him competition and more importantly, as cover if he gets crocked.
guinless
I'm now very worried............
Old Big 'Ed
Guinless - I think you're being harsh, we certainly did not deserve to lose & their keeper made some fantastic saves, Bennetts header, Commons free kick, Holt missed 2 really good chances (the one before half time was harder to miss), Commons missed chances & looked dangerous 1st half, Clingan bossed the midfield. Where I saw the problem was a very weak & inexperienced bench; no striker, Richardson & Lockwood (nuff said), Davies (needs a regular start - looks good in patches), McCleary (giving a 5 minute debut on left wing gave us nothing) & Thornhill. No impact players from the bench & with a tiring Agogo & Holt - there were no replacements. Smith is a great keeper but will make mistakes, the goal was pure luck for Carlisle & indeed some refs may have given a free kick - which I thought Smith was playing for - but you are right in that he has no competition! All in all I felt we were unlucky & now need to make sone of the away games count - this may be the kick up the arse we need to do this OR to prompt the club into bolstering the squad!
Our Kids Dad
After all your possesion and attempts at goal you really should have won this game!
will it ever happen
I don't see it as Smith's mistake, your defender just stood there and watched the race for the ball, he was facing play and should have taken control of the situation and cleared the ball for a corner. End of any chance of the title now
cyjax
Bad result for you guys, and me I backed you not to lose !
Eddie01
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. PVH 564
2. da fuq 436
3. Calvin Plummer 358
4. toms 324
5. Jimmy Gordon 291
6. the jock 290
7. LyttleByLyttle 288
8. Pope John XXIII 246
9. MarvinsPA 240
10. RedSmedDownUnder 204

League Results (view all)

Latest Results

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
8. Cardiff 0 0 0 0 0 0
9. Charlton 0 0 0 0 0 0
10. Derby County 0 0 0 0 0 0
11. Forest 0 0 0 0 0 0
12. Fulham 0 0 0 0 0 0
13. Huddersfield 0 0 0 0 0 0
14. Ipswich 0 0 0 0 0 0

Breaking League News

Fer, Olsson And RvW Set To Leave
Norwich : 29/07/2014 07:33:00
LUFC On This Day - July 29th
Leeds Utd : 29/07/2014 07:27:00
Brentford Turn Down Latics Bid For Forshaw
Wigan : 28/07/2014 20:50:00
Clarke Returns to Familiar Settings
Huddersfield : 28/07/2014 20:31:00
LUFC White set to miss start of season
Leeds Utd : 28/07/2014 20:30:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Djamel Abdoun is yet to find a new club - would you keep him to see if he can turn his Forest career
Suggested By:  OKD
Yes - given current injuries 86%
No - get rid asap 14%